The Nomenclature of ‘Metroidvania’ and the Case to Abandon It

Though less "abandon" and more "make a small change".

“Metroidvania” is a term that was coined many years ago by Scott Sharkey and popularized by Jeremy Parish, first to describe the Castlevania games from Konami which had adopted elements from Nintendo’s Metroid series. Eventually, it would come to commonly be used as the name for the genre of games which has followed in the footsteps of those two series.

The term has met with some pushback for various reasons, not the least of which is the issue of dealing with trademarks. After all, what good is a genre descriptor if you can’t even include it on your game’s box? No one who hopes to make something big out of their own video game wants to risk incurring the wrath of Nintendo. (Why not Konami? We’ll get into that.)

Even Koji Igarashi, the man who helped steer the Castlevania series in the direction which inspired the name, was reticent about using it after leaving Konami. When it came time to pitch his spiritual successor for the series, Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night, on Kickstarter, he instead referred to it as an “Igavania.” According to Wikipedia, other terms used for it have included “platform-adventure,” and in Japan, “exploratory world,” though apparently “Metroidvania” only recently began to propagate over there around the turn of the decade. “Search action” has also been seen around.

For the most part, it’s been a general non-issue. Some people prefer to use the term, others prefer one of the different ones named above.

Then came a new trailer for an indie game which, perhaps inadvertently, served to highlight the problem:

The title, of course, is what sparked some debate about the subject on some forums I frequent. The person who posted it said it was “cruisin’ for a lawsuit,” and pointed out that the creators behind this project were naming their game after a genre that explicitly uses a trademarked term, and that said term is owned by a company who is known for being fairly litigious. Someone else replied that there was a good argument that “Metroidvania” has been genericized enough that Nintendo wouldn’t have a legal leg to stand on.

Incidentally, to that later argument? I’m pretty sure any legal defense an indie company could muster would be soundly trampled by Nintendo’s own counsel. And while I’m sure Nintendo could withstand any blowback they’d receive from “picking on the little guy,” it’s also possible that the developers could be figuratively pilloried in the court of public opinion by Nintendo fans.

That said, Nintendo might be more likely to just send a C&D (cease and desist), and kill the name that way.

As to the issue of genericization, I’m not a lawyer, but there have been cases where a brand name has been used enough as a generic term that the trademark was weakened. “Thermos,” “zipper,” and “linoleum” are a few such terms, while others have managed to become genericized while retaining their trademark — for instance, have you “photoshopped” or “googled” or “xeroxed” anything lately?

It’s something that Nintendo has taken an active stance against in the past, during that period where our parents, grandparents, aunts, and uncles would all refer to any video game console as “a Nintendo”, whether it was made by the Kyoto-based company or not:

One example that comes to mind of brand genericization is Hasbro’s Transformers line. In more recent years, they’ve avoided using the term “transform” as a verb, since doing so would apparently make the name descriptive, and thus indefensible. This has resulted in things like changing the language on packaging to say that Transformers “convert” to different modes, rather than “transform.” Even Optimus Prime’s famous battle cry, “transform and roll out!” was affected by this, though in even more recent years, it seems they’ve dialed it back a little bit.

TFWiki has a very thorough article about trademarks, including a specific section on genericization. (There’s one for copyright, too, which is a separate matter.)

But back to the main issue at hand, which is not Transformers, but Metroid. As one person in the thread noted, “Metroid” is not a generic word, but actually a very specific, trademarked word. And that, of course, is where the crux of the problem lies.

Personally speaking, I have an idea that manages to maintain the general familiarity and meaning of the genre name while also making it more trademark-friendly.

And all it takes is dropping two little letters.

Breaking down “Metroidvania” into its two contributing components, it’s a portmanteau of “Metroid” and “Castlevania”. Helpfully, Castlevania‘s contribution is simply the suffix “-vania,” which I’m reasonably confident is not able to be trademarked or defended on its own. It’s not only a part of the name “Castlevania,” but also various real-world places, such as Pennsylvania or, you know, Transylvania.

“Metroid,” the more contestable component, is itself a portmanteau of two other words. According to Nintendo, it “comes from combining ‘metro’ (in the sense of an underground transit system) with ‘android’ (a humanoid robot).”

Now, as cool as they are, I think it could be agreed that androids are not a fundamental component of a Metroidvania. Case in point: The whole Castlevania part.

That leaves us with the other part, “metro.” Ah, now we’re getting somewhere.

The “metro” prefix is meant to convey the underground tunnels of a transit system. If you compare the map of one such system…

…to maps from some of the more popular entries/namesakes of the genre…

…I believe one can see the resemblance/inspiration, as the in-game maps don’t look unlike a map of a real-world metro system.

As such, I think just knocking two little letters out of the word “Metroidvania” would solve a number of issues. “Metrovania” still respects the genre’s roots by evoking the original meanings of the word and the trademarked word-within-a-word, while still being trademark-friendly.

I mean, I guess there’s also “Castleroid.” I don’t think anyone could do anything about that.

—

Thanks for reading!

If you like what we’re doing, please consider chipping in a few bucks our way on Patreon, Ko-fi, or even just something via PayPal. Maybe then we can do something about our current seating situation, and get something that allows Nadia to play longer and/or more frequently! Every little bit helps!

Filed under...Video Games

Prev/Next in Category(s)

Prev/Next by Date

Comments